10 March 2015

Coquelin clobbers Matić, so who needs another DM? Not Arsenal...

Since his return from his most recent loan-spell at Charlton, it seems that Francis Coquelin has set the world on fire with his performances, almost singlehandedly resurrecting an Arsenal season that looked like it might have otherwise ended in ignominious fashion. From Boxing Day forward, Coquelin has become a bedrock in the defensive midfield, so much so that Arteta and Flamini have been all but forgotten, so much so that Arsène felt confident enough in Coquelin to sign only 17-year-old Krystian Bielik to buttress the defensive midfield, refusing to dig any deeper than £2.7m or so to reinforce what has arguably been one of our weakest positions over the last few seasons. Now, with Coquelin's emergence, it seems as if all of our prayers have been answered. For one, he bests Chelsea's Nemanja Matić. Actually, that—that should settle the debate right there. Right?


After all, Matić is widely regarded as one of the better defensive midfielders in the Prem, and rightly so. When you see a graphic that shows that Coq surpasses Matić in most categories, well, that proves something, doesn't it? Coq gets more blocks, clearances, tackles, aerial duels, and interceptions than Chelsea's man, so the debate is settled and we can sleep easy knowing that our back-four is finally shielded properly by a fiery, French DM with five syllables to his name. Vieira's heir, indeed. 

 However, before we go anointing Coquelin just yet, let's remind ourselves that his sample-size is minuscule, diminished even further by the fact that many of our opponents were hardly top-drawer (no offense, various opponents). For example, Hull and Stoke were abysmal by any standard. We might have steam-rolled Aston Villa with your correspondent as DM. Let's not forget that Coquelin was involved in our debacles against Southampton, Tottenham, and Monaco. More impressively, he's played a key role in defeating both Manchesters—although City were without Yaya Touré. Of his thirteen starts, he's certainly done well for himself, but it's far too early to crown him as our DM of the future. The sample-size is too small and too pock-marked by asterisks and addendums to draw any broad, sweeping conclusions. 

 Then again, we have to know that Flamini's contract expires in June, and he's not getting any faster or more-technically astute. Arteta seems more likely to best Mertesacker and milk in a "who turns slowest" contest than he is to find any kind of fountain of youth. After they're put out to pasture, we have Cazorla, Ramsey, and Wilshere, who are better-known for getting forward than they are at defending deep. That is to say, Coquelin stands alone, literally and figuratively, as a player who is willing to get down and dirty to disrupt our opponents. Even at their best, Flamini and Arteta are fingers in a leaky dam, and one or the other is on the pitch with Mertesacker, our defense gets slower than molasses in January.

Coquelin
Schneiderlin
Bender
Matić
League Matches
13
20
19
25
Tackles
3.5
3.3
3.1
3.8
Interceptions
3.2
2.4
2.8
1.7
Aerial Duels Won
3.2
1.8
4.9
1.9
Fouls Committed
1.2
2.0
1.3
2.3
Clearances
4.2
1.6
2.4
2.8
Blocks
0.5
0.2
NA
0.2
Pass Completion
83.6%
89.3%
68.7%
89.9%
Transfer fee (est.)
0
£25m
£19m
£30m
Statistics courtesy of whoscored.com

Stated more plainly, we're going to need reinforcements in the more-defensive midfield area this summer. Who's it going to be? We've been heavily linked to Morgan Schneiderlin, William Carvalho, and Lars Bender, among others. Southampton and Sporting would likely demand princely sums for their players, and even if Bayer Leverkusen are more willing to haggle over Bender, we have to ask ourselves what makes the most sense. Even with admitting the somewhat-limited sample size we're working with, Coquelin does stack up well against the more-pedigreed players against whom he might be compared. In fact, according to the graphic above, he bests those players in more categories than not. Should Coquelin continue to play to the level we've seen over the last three or four months, we may settle at least one question regarding our defense. This is not to say that we should stand pat in the summer, not by a long shot. Flamini and Arteta might have another season left in them, but I'd suggest that we've already seen their best, and their best hasn't been good enough for our ambitions. 

Time will tell whether Coquelin surpasses that standard, in this season and beyond. As we weigh up those ambitions and attendant needs, whom should we target come summer? Is £25m for Schneiderlin, for example, commensurate with our needs, or could we take next steps with Coquelin in a holding role while Ramsey, Wilshere, and Cazorla get forward? We do have to mind the fact that Coquelin will need competition if not relief, and so one question among many will be, how much are we willing to spend for that competition, that rotation, that relief? As always, answers to these and other questions will depend on how we fare on three fronts, the Prem, the FA Cup, and the Champions League. At the moment, we have to feel pretty good about the first two and a bit wobbly about the last one. 

In any case, we're currently Coq of the walk, at least for a few more days until the next result. I hope it's not too much a wet blanket to suggest that Coquelin is not (yet) the saviour we clamour for. A few more performances like the one on Monday, though, might just be enough to sway me. Until next time, thanks, as always, for the visit. Before you go, weigh in: is Coquelin good enough to help us win the FA Cup, finish third (or higher) in the Prem, or advance in the Champions League? Should we target another DM in the summer window, and if so, who? For now, we have the luxury of debating such trifles. A penny for your thoughts...

Add your comments to the debate going on below, and don't be afraid of a shout-out via twitter, reddit, or facebook either. Thanks for stopping by!